How to Measure the Real ROI of Online Review Campaigns

Jared

Jared

— 3 min read
How to Measure the Real ROI of Online Review Campaigns
Photo by Lukas Blazek / Unsplash

Online reviews aren’t just about vanity metrics—they’re a powerful business asset. Yet many companies struggle to quantify their true value. In 2025, with tools more advanced than ever, it’s finally possible to tie reviews directly to ROI. The challenge is knowing what to measure and how to measure it.

This article breaks down how modern businesses can calculate the return on investment (ROI) from review campaigns, from increased visibility to revenue growth, and everything in between.

Why ROI From Reviews Matters

Businesses are investing time, money, and platforms like One All Ratings into growing their reviews. Measuring ROI:

  • Justifies review program budgets
  • Helps optimize campaign performance
  • Clarifies what’s working and what’s not

Without ROI tracking, review campaigns can feel like a shot in the dark.

What Counts as “Return” in Review Campaigns?

1. Increased Local Search Visibility

  • Higher rankings in the Google Local Pack
  • Better CTR from organic search results
  • More impressions for branded and non-branded keywords

2. Website Traffic and Conversions

  • More visits from GMB and review-rich pages
  • Increased conversion rate due to social proof
  • Longer dwell time and reduced bounce rate

3. Lead Generation and Revenue

  • More form submissions and phone calls
  • Higher average order value from influenced customers
  • Increased bookings, signups, or sales

4. Brand Trust and Reputation Metrics

  • Star rating improvements
  • Sentiment analysis over time
  • Customer satisfaction and NPS alignment

Metrics to Track When Measuring Review ROI

Local SEO Metrics:

  • Map Pack Position: Before/after campaign
  • Click-Through Rate (CTR): Measured via Google Search Console
  • Impression Share: For branded queries and local terms

Website Metrics:

  • Referral Traffic: From Google Business Profile, Yelp, etc.
  • Time on Page: On pages featuring reviews
  • Conversion Rate: Split-tested with/without reviews

Reputation Metrics:

  • Star Rating Average: Baseline vs. post-campaign
  • Review Count: Growth over campaign period
  • Review Velocity: Consistency of new feedback

Financial Metrics:

  • Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC): With and without reviews
  • Lifetime Value (LTV): For customers influenced by reviews
  • Revenue per Campaign: Direct attributions via promo links, tracking numbers

Tools That Help Measure Review ROI

1. Google Business Profile Insights

Provides data on views, actions, and user engagement with listings.

2. Google Analytics & GA4

Tracks how review-driven traffic behaves on your site.

3. Looker Studio Dashboards

Custom reporting dashboards that integrate review performance with business KPIs.

4. One All Ratings Platform

  • Tracks review submission rates
  • Links reviews to transaction IDs
  • Measures engagement impact across campaigns

5. Call Tracking Tools (e.g., CallRail)

Assigns unique numbers to review listings to measure calls from GMB, Yelp, etc.

How to Attribute Revenue to Review Campaigns

Step 1: Set Clear KPIs

  • New review volume
  • GMB calls or direction requests
  • Site visits from review pages

Step 2: Establish Baselines

Before launching a campaign, document your current metrics.

Step 3: Track Post-Campaign Impact

Monitor changes across local rankings, traffic, leads, and sales.

Step 4: Use Attribution Models

  • First-touch attribution: Customer discovers brand via reviews
  • Last-touch attribution: Review seals the deal
  • Linear attribution: Reviews influence customer across journey

Step 5: Survey Customers

Ask “What influenced your decision?” and quantify review impact directly.

Case Study: Measuring ROI from a Review Campaign

Business: Multi-location HVAC company
Problem: Spending heavily on PPC with low trust factor Action:

  • Launched review request campaigns via One All Ratings
  • Featured reviews on homepage and service pages
  • Added UTM parameters to review funnel links

Results Over 6 Months:

  • 118% increase in GMB calls
  • 39% increase in organic search clicks
  • 24% decrease in CAC
  • Attributed $87,000 in new business from tracked review traffic

Pitfalls to Avoid When Measuring ROI

  • Not Segmenting Campaigns: Organic reviews vs. incentivized efforts
  • Relying Only on Star Ratings: Focus on volume, recency, sentiment
  • Ignoring Indirect Impact: Reviews drive SEO, which drives visibility
  • Forgetting Lifetime Value: Reviews attract better-fit, more loyal customers

Final Thoughts: Reviews Are Measurable—If You Plan Right

Reviews influence behavior. They build trust. They drive clicks. And now, with the right setup, they drive measurable ROI.

Instead of treating reviews as a fuzzy branding exercise, smart businesses treat them as a performance channel.

The formula is simple:

  1. Set KPIs
  2. Track with precision
  3. Attribute correctly
  4. Optimize continuously

Do this, and your next review campaign won’t just look good—it’ll pay off in real dollars.

Read more